As a handyman or handyman contractor, having proper insurance coverage is crucial to protecting your business. Workers’ compensation insurance specifically helps cover costs if an employee is injured on the job. Without adequate coverage, a single employee injury could devastate your company’s finances.

This comprehensive guide will explain everything handymen need to know about securing the right workers’ compensation policy. We’ll cover key topics in depth like:

  • What Is Workers’ Compensation Insurance?
  • Why Handymen Need Workers’ Comp
  • What Does Workers’ Comp Insurance Cover?
  • Exclusions to Be Aware Of
  • How Much Does Workers’ Comp Cost for Handymen?
  • Strategies to Reduce Your Workers’ Comp Premiums
  • How To Get Tailored Workers’ Comp Coverage

Read on for a detailed overview of how workers’ compensation insurance works and why handymen need appropriate protection.

What is Workers’ Compensation Insurance?

Workers’ compensation insurance provides medical, rehabilitation, and wage replacement benefits to employees who sustain injuries or illnesses arising out of the course of their work.

As a handyman, your employees may be injured on the job in a variety of ways – back injuries from lifting heavy objects; lacerations from tools and debris; respiratory issues from dust and chemicals; slips, trips and falls at client sites, and more.

Workers’ compensation coverage pays for their medical treatment and compensates for a portion of lost wages while injured.

This insurance is mandatory for nearly all employers in the US. Even in states where it is optional, it is critically important. Without workers’ compensation, injured employees could sue your business directly to recover costs. This could absorb hundreds of thousands in legal fees and settlements.

Workers’ compensation laws are determined on a state-by-state basis but have some common elements:

  • No-fault coverage – Benefits must be paid regardless of who was at fault for an injury.
  • Exclusive remedy – Prevents separate lawsuits against the employer. Workers’ comp is the exclusive remedy.
  • Mandatory coverage – Nearly every state requires coverage with few exceptions. Failing to carry this insurance leads to significant fines.
  • Employer-financed – Employers foot the bill for all premiums. Employees are not required to contribute.

As the employer, it is your responsibility to purchase adequate workers’ compensation for all your staff and maintain compliance with your state’s guidelines. Failing to do so poses tremendous financial risks to your handyman business.

Why Do Handymen Need Workers’ Comp Insurance?

Due to the physical nature of handyman work, employee injuries are common. Situations requiring workers’ compensation benefits could include:

  • Back sprains, hernias, and other muscular injuries from lifting heavy appliances, furniture, or construction materials.
  • Lacerations or amputations from sharp tools, debris, and handling damaged items with nails, glass or other hazards.
  • Respiratory issues like asthma attacks triggered by irritants like sawdust, insulation, mold, chemicals.
  • Electrical shocks and burns from faulty wiring and electrical systems being repaired.
  • Concussions, fractures, and sprains from falls off ladders, stairs, or rooftops during installations and repairs.
  • Eye injuries like particles or chemicals lodged in eyes during demolition, sanding, sawing etc.

Even with safety precautions, handymen jobs carry inherent risks on a daily basis. The financial costs of these employee injuries can easily climb into the tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars when medical bills and lost wages add up.

Having proper workers’ compensation insurance coverage is the only way to cover these costs without financial disaster. It helps keep your business afloat if an on-the-job accident occurs by paying for the injury. This insurance is just as crucial as general liability coverage for handymen to have ironclad protection.

Moreover, nearly every state requires handymen to carry workers’ compensation insurance on their employees. Even in monopolistic states where coverage must be purchased through a state-run fund, handymen must still carry this insurance. These states include North Dakota, Ohio, Washington, and Wyoming.

All states require workers’ compensation except Texas and Oklahoma. In Texas, workers’ comp insurance is optional for handymen. However, ~90% still choose to purchase this coverage to limit liability. If not carried, employees can sue the handyman directly for injuries. In Oklahoma, workers’ comp is optional for very small employers with 1 or 2 employees, which may apply to some self-employed handymen or tiny firms. Firms with more than 2 employees must carry comp insurance in Oklahoma.

The vast majority of handymen are required to carry workers’ compensation insurance on their staff in nearly every state. Only a small subset of solo self-employed handymen or micro firms may potentially not be required in Texas and Oklahoma depending on size. However, even in these two states coverage is still highly recommended to avoid lawsuits. Every other state mandates workers’ comp.

What Does Workers’ Comp Insurance Cover for Handymen?

Workers’ compensation insurance policies are designed to accomplish two things if an employee is hurt while working:

  1. Pay the employee’s medical bills and directly related expenses. This includes hospital fees, physical therapy, doctor visits, prescription medications, medical equipment, home health care, and any other medical costs stemming from the work injury. There are no caps or limits on the amount of medical coverage provided.
  2. Reimburse a portion of the employee’s lost wages while they recover. The specifics on wage reimbursement percentages and duration limits depend on individual state laws. Most states cover around 2/3 of the employee’s average wages up to state maximums.

Additional benefits covered may include:

  • Death benefits for surviving dependents if an employee passes away due to a workplace injury or illness. Most states provide both burial costs and wage replacement.
  • Vocational rehabilitation to help injured employees transition back to work or train for a new occupation if they cannot continue handyman work due to permanent disability.
  • Mileage reimbursement for trips to doctor appointments and medical facilities.

Workers’ compensation is intended to cover all reasonable and directly related medical, rehabilitative, and wage replacement costs to help the injured employee fully recover and get back to work if possible.

It’s important to understand workers’ compensation insurance only applies to injuries occurring within the scope of employment. Key exclusions to be aware of include:

  • Injuries occurring outside of work hours or off company premises. There must be a clear connection to work duties.
  • Pre-existing health conditions that are aggravated or exacerbated by work activities. The injury itself must arise out of employment.
  • Intentionally self-inflicted injuries such as suicide attempts and self-harm activities.
  • Injuries occurring when an employee violates policy such as fighting, committing crimes, or intoxication at work.
  • Ordinary diseases of life like colds, flu, allergies etc. that are not caused solely by work duties.
  • Gradual hearing loss or repetitive motion injuries that occur slowly over time. These may be disputed by insurers.

Any gray areas or disputes will be evaluated on a case-by-case basis. But in general, workers’ compensation insurance covers only identifiable injuries resulting from the employee’s job duties. Other key coverages like health insurance help fill gaps that workers’ comp does not address.

What Does Workers’ Comp Insurance Cost for Handymen?

Workers’ compensation insurance costs vary greatly by state since each state governs the specifics of coverage required within its borders. Rates are also driven by the classification or risk-level of the handyman’s employees. Handymen are generally classified under code 5645, which is a moderately high risk occupation class.

Handymen can expect to pay between $5 – $17+ per $100 of payroll towards workers’ compensation premiums. Several variables affect handyman workers’ comp premiums. Understanding their influence is crucial for effective cost management.

Classification Codes and Base Rates

The National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) assigns classification codes to various professions reflecting their inherent risk levels. Handymen are commonly classified under:

  • Code 5645 – Carpentry: Covers trim, finish, and rough carpentry. Applies to general handyman tasks like installing cabinets or building shelving. This is typically the code that handymen use.
  • Code 5651 – Plumbing, Heating, Air Conditioning: For any plumbing repairs like fixing leaks or replacing fixtures. Also covers HVAC work.
  • Code 5606 – Miscellaneous Specialty Trade Contractors: A catch-all code for unique specialty handyman work not covered by other classifications.

These codes have set base rates per $100 of payroll, published annually by the NCCI. Insurers use the codes and base rates together with other factors to calculate premiums. Accurate classification is important to prevent overpaying for risk exposures exceeding a handyman’s actual work.

Experience Modification Rating (EMR)

The EMR compares past loss history to industry averages to project future claim likelihood. New businesses have an EMR of 1.0, representing the industry baseline. Higher EMRs indicate greater incurred losses and expected risk, increasing premiums. Lower EMRs reflect safer history and decrease costs.

Controlling and reducing EMR over time through effective safety and claims management is a key strategy for handymen to lower premium expenses. Preventing injuries keeps EMR lower.

Estimated Payroll

Premiums relate directly to employee payroll, with rates applied per $100 of payroll. Payroll generally reflects compensation over a set period, normally the prior year. Regional differences in pay scales lead to varying premium costs.

Properly classifying payroll by employee type and exposure prevents overpaying premiums for riskier activities exceeding actual handyman work. Office staff may fall under lower rate codes than working handymen facing more physical exposures. Detailed payroll records ensure accurate premium calculation during audits.

Premium Calculation Formula

These primary factors determine workers’ comp premiums through the following formula:

Premium = Base Rate x EMR x (Payroll / 100)

Higher base rates, EMR multipliers, and payroll inputs mean greater overall workers’ compensation costs. Managing these key variables through a focus on safety, proper employee classification, and meticulous payroll reporting allows handymen to exert more control over premium expenses.

Risks Driving Up Handymen’s Premiums

The hands-on nature of handyman work involves many inherent safety hazards and accidents risks. Common exposures include:

  • Lifting, carrying, and moving heavy equipment, appliances, and materials leading to back injuries and strains.
  • Operating power tools like saws, drills, sanders and other dangerous electrical equipment that can cause lacerations or amputations.
  • Working at height on ladders, roofs, and other elevated surfaces resulting in falls.
  • Using toxic chemicals in paints, adhesives, and other building products that pose health risks.
  • Slip, trip, and fall hazards on uneven job sites cluttered with obstacles and debris.
  • Repetitive motion from frequent tool use, carrying, and working in awkward positions leading to ergonomic injuries like carpal tunnel syndrome.
  • Motor vehicle accidents traveling to and from client sites.
  • Unexpected events like encountering live wires hidden behind walls.

These inherent risks mean more frequent and severe claims for handymen compared to less hazardous professions. As a result, handyman classification codes have significantly higher base rates which drive up premium expenses. A constant focus on safety is critical to help control risks and prevent costly injuries. Here you can learn more about the steps for a handyman to reduce hazards and worker’s compensation claims.

EMR Multiplier Effect on Premium Costs

As a major component in the workers’ compensation premium formula, small changes in a handyman business’ EMR can substantially impact bottom line costs. For example, consider a company with:

  • $150,000 in Estimated Annual Payroll
  • Base Rate of $7.50 per $100 of payroll

Scenario 1: EMR of 0.90
Premium = $7.50 x 0.90 x ($150,000 / 100) = $10,125

Scenario 2: EMR of 1.15
Premium = $7.50 x 1.15 x ($150,000 / 100) = $12,937

Here, a 0.25 increase in the EMR multiplies the premium by about 28% or $2,812 annually. While controlling all cost factors is important, keeping the EMR low through prevention and safety pays dividends for handymen seeking affordable workers’ comp.

Handyman Workers’ Comp Premium Calculator

To estimate potential workers’ comp costs based on your unique business parameters, use our handyman premium calculator:

Input your key variables like payroll, employee class codes, and your current or estimated EMR to receive an indicative premium estimate. This allows handymen to model different scenarios to optimize affordability.

Comparing quotes from multiple insurers and independent agents using your calculator outputs can also help find the best rate. Make sure to confirm all policy details before purchasing a policy.

Workers’ Comp Costs by State for Handymen

Workers’ compensation costs can vary widely for handymen based on the state in which they operate. Some states have vastly higher premiums driven by different regulations, baseline rates, and higher wages impacting payroll factors.

Below are two tables illustrating typical costs per handyman employee and per $100,000 in payroll across all 50 states plus Washington DC:

Table 1 – Typical Workers’ Compensation Premium Cost per Handyman Employee

StateTypical Cost of WC per Employee
New Hampshire$4,689
New Jersey$8,441
New Mexico$5,067
New York$5,645
North Carolina$6,622
North Dakota$1,628
Rhode Island$4,790
South Carolina$6,653
South Dakota$4,148
West Virginia$2,310

Table 2 – Typical Handyman Workers’ Compensation Premium Cost per $100K Payroll

StateTypical Cost of WC per $100K payroll
District of Columbia$7,060
New Hampshire$9,540
New Jersey$17,090
New Mexico$12,780
New York$11,470
North Carolina$16,730
North Dakota$3,510
Rhode Island$9,030
South Carolina$16,220
South Dakota$10,290
West Virginia$5,720

Handyman Classification vs Contractors

Some handymen may ask whether they can be classified under lower risk contraction codes instead of the assigned handyman classifications. However, attempting to misreport employee duties or profession constitutes fraud. Insurers assign specific codes like 5645 for Carpentry based on the hazardous trade exposures of handymen.

During payroll audits, insurers carefully examine actual daily work activities, tools used, materials handled and services provided. Any material misrepresentation of tradesman risk would be uncovered, and could prompt penalties in addition to premium back payments.

For companies with separate handyman and general contracting staff, it may be permissible and advantageous to split payroll across codes based on actual differing exposures. But workers primarily performing handyman tasks will likely remain under the higher hazard trade class codes that reflect their work activities.

The strategic allocation of employees to appropriate class codes based on unique risks is key to optimizing workers’ comp costs. But misrepresentation of exposures could backfire significantly. Partnering with an experienced broker can ensure proper classification and documentation.

What Can Handymen Do To Reduce Workers’ Comp Costs?

As a substantial fixed cost, controlling workers’ compensation premiums is important for handymen. The most impactful way handymen can reduce their workers’ compensation costs is to focus on safety. Preventing workplace injuries before they happen saves significant money. Maintaining thorough safety protocols and a clean loss run history over time can lower your premiums. Some cost reduction strategies include:

  • 1 Prevent Claims. By enforcing robust safety protocols such as proper lifting techniques, tool handling, fall protection, and regular training, you can prevent workplace incidents. This is the #1 way to lower premiums over time because it’s reflected in your Experience Modification calculation (or X Mod). This calculation represents the likelihood your business will have a claim (based on historical claims) and has a direct impact on your premium.
  • Providing the right protective gear like back braces, gloves, goggles, hard hats, and hearing protection to mitigate risks. Conduct regular job site assessments to identify potential hazards.
  • Training workers on electrical, fire, and chemical safety when doing repair work to avoid burns, shocks, and respiratory issues.
  • Applying proper safety guards and switches to power tools and ensuring regular maintenance. Watch for frayed cords. Unplug tools when not in use.
  • Promptly reporting all claims. Late claims can lead to fines from the state and much higher future premiums. Report injuries ASAP even if you are unsure a claim will be filed.
  • Partnering with a specialist broker to customize your policy and find potential savings. They can ensure proper classification codes are applied and find applicable discounts.

Understanding Class Codes and Payroll Split for Handymen

For handymen, properly classifying employees and managing payroll records is vital to controlling workers’ compensation costs. Handyman staff generally fall under the class code – 5645.

Being classified under the wrong codes can significantly inflate premiums. For example, a clerical worker wrongly classified as a handyman under code 5645 could increase costs unnecessarily. Partnering with a specialist familiar with handyman class codes helps avoid overpaying premiums.

In addition, for employees doing multiple jobs, properly splitting payroll between classifications is permitted in most states. This “labor interchange” must be recorded accurately per hour/day to allow for payroll division. Vague or inaccurate job descriptions can lead to misclassification.

However, clerical staff payroll cannot be divided. There are four standard exception codes including clerical, sales, drafting, and executive duties where splitting is prohibited. Understanding these nuances is key to optimizing workers’ comp costs.

With handymen, both payroll size and proper classification directly impact premiums. Keeping detailed payroll records, correctly applying codes, and working with experienced agents saves money on workers’ compensation insurance. Mistakes can lead to substantial unexpected costs.

How Can Handymen Get Tailored Workers’ Comp Insurance?

The workers’ compensation system can be complex to navigate with strict state and federal regulations. Mistakes in classification codes, Experience Mod calculations, and reporting claims can be very costly.

When seeking coverage, partnering with insurance specialists focused on the handyman trades is highly recommended. Avoid a one-size-fits-all policy from an insurance carrier’s website or call center.

Some key benefits of using handyman trade specialists include:

  • Access to top regional and national insurers familiar with handyman risks who actively write these policies for handymen. Captive handyman insurance agents only work with select carriers.
  • Compliance expertise to steer you clear of violations and help manage claims appropriately. Confidently handle audits. Mistakes lead to fines.
  • Potential access to handyman trade association plans not available to the general public. Group plans through NAHB, NHCA, NARI etc. can offer discounted rates.
  • Policy customization based on your unique mix of employees. Classifying payroll correctly optimizes your rate.
  • Bundle discounts when pairing workers’ comp with general liability and other coverages. This lowers insurance overhead.
  • Risk management guidance like job site assessments, OSHA advice, and safety program creation. Lower risks lead to lower premiums.
  • Claims assistance including investigation, directing medical care, coordinating return to work and settlement. Leave the paperwork to the experts.

The right insurance partner takes the burden of handling complex workers’ compensation requirements off your shoulders. This allows you to focus on your handyman business rather than insurance administration. Avoid roadblocks to smooth operation.

Get Handymen Workers Comp in Minutes

Need workers comp for your handyman business? Get quotes fast from ContractorNerd.

Simply enter details about your handyman payroll, employees and work history. Instantly compare multiple workers comp quotes customized for handymen and home repair services.

Benefits Include:

  • Quick handyman payroll-based quotes
  • Policies from top national carriers
  • Tailored limits and optional coverages
  • Bundle with handyman general liability
  • Support from handyman insurance experts

Save time. Get obligation-free workers comp quotes for your handyman business now. Stay protected and ensure state compliance.